Col. Mustard's Sports Bar & Lounge Markham

First time trying the place out and it happen to be during Game 6-7 of the World Series...and despite the place being absolutely slammed with people the wait staff was polite as responsive as possible given the number of people and the food was never subpar, everything we ordered arrived correctly and hot which really was amazing.

This might just become a regular spot for us to watch sporting events going forward

Always drive past here, first time I've come in. The interior is very nice, stage for karaoke, pool table, darts, and lots of TVs. The hostess/bartender is such a wonderful person. She's very kind. The food is cheaply priced but the quality is top tier. Portions are huge. $18 for a HUGE burger, beer, and side. Excellent to watch any sports games in or just to hang out. Highly recommend

2024 January 3★
You're looking for a place to hang, this is it. Most of the patrons appear to come here again and again as the waitress knows them by name.
Friday night is karaoke night and adds to the entertainment. Though the music they play is certainly good as well.

Pub food.
Jug Rickards Red $25
Whiskey Sour $8.25
Pina Colada $9
Tequilla Sunrise $9.75
All drinks were good. Not overly expensive either.

Nachos supreme $14 + Add Butter Chicken $4 - not bad, but would pass next time. Wings are a better option.

Fish and chips $18 - light and crispy. Beer batter style. Pretty decent.

2lbs wings and fries $24 - chicken pieces were pretty large, crispy and good if you ate them when they came out. They do get drier once it gets cold.

For amusement, they have:
Dart board - but bring your own darts. Playing cards if asked
Karaoke on Fridays and I believe Saturdays too.

It's not a bad hangout with friends. It's not busy that they rush you to leave either. Worth checking out.

Open late | Tuesday wing specials | Drink specials | Patio seating | ATM | Darts | TVs

3rd update of my review (most recent one was 2018 February)

Came in on Tuesday at 11:15pm and they were still opened with wing special available. They said last call at 12:45am. There were only 3 customers left inside. They offered a "late night menu" though.

Late night menu include but not limited to: salads, bruschetta, chicken rolls, calamari, potato skins, wings, chicken fingers, poutine, onion rings etc.

Tuesday wing specials are 99 cent with minimum order of 6 wings per order. MENU SAYS they come with carrots and celery, and your choice of ranch/ dill/ blue cheese dressing. ... We only got wings and nothing else. BUT maybe that's the regular late night menu and Tuesday wing specials don't include it ....
We ordered a ranch sauce after ....

Wing sauces:
- Wet (BBQ, honey garlic, medium, hot, suicide, sweet chilli, Jamaican jerk, teriyaki, hot-honey)
- Dry (Cajun, Juanita, lemon pepper, salt & pepper
[Extra sauce $1.00, split flavours $1.00, carrots & celery $3]

They have a variety of Molson beers on tap. The overall feel is still the same.

My last review said the wings were ok sized but wings were dry and felt refried. A year later, I feel the same. They were about 2" in length and even with wet sauce (I ordered hot honey and medium) they were still dry and hard. They were nice and hot though. The medium was barely spicy though. The dry Cajun was very dry buy barely Cajun ....

We were also not given a bucket for bones. With 4 orders of wings our plates were filled with bones and unable to use it without combining the wing baskets so that we can use one for bones.

There was only one server for the whole restaurant. She was sweet.

Overall I'm a bit disappointed that there's no improvement in wings quality or false advertising of carrots/celery and dressing being included. But happy they stay open late and still offer the special.